Evaluating Books, Journals, Journal Articles and Websites
11 rows · Non-scholarly sources are intended to do several things: to provide general information, to. Apr 22, · Non Scholarly Sources: May claim to be citing credible sources, but they may not actually be May not acknowledge the ongoing conversation surrounding the issue May present knowledge as the ultimate truth, the one right perspective on a topicAuthor: Winn Wasson.
Choosing the right sources for your research can be challenging. A variety of options are available, including books, articles and websites. Different sources can provide different types of information:. Use a book when you require background information and related research on a topic, when you want to add depth to a research topic or put your topic in context with other important issues.
Disadvantages: Because it can take years, in some instances, to write and publish books, they are not always the best sources for current topic.
Advantages: The articles found in many scholarly journals go through a "peer-review" process. In other words, the articles are checked by academics and other experts. The information is therefore reliable. Use scholarly journals when you what are non scholarly sources original research on a topic; articles what is the cutoff to file taxes essays written by scholars or subject experts; factual documented information to reinforce a position; or references lists that point you to other relevant research.
Scholarly journals take less time to publish than books, but the peer-review process can be lengthy. Disadvantages: Scholarly journals include information of academic interest, so they are not the best sources for general interest topics. Because the peer-review process can be time-consuming, they may not what is chief keef net worth up-to-the minute news or current event information.
Advantages: Websites provide up-to-the minute news and information about current events, trends, and controversial topics. Disadvantages: Because anyone can publish anything on the web, website information may be inaccurate or biased, and sometimes outdated.
Only a very limited amount of scholarly information is available on the open web. View the video Why can't I just Google? Search this Guide Search. Evaluating Books, Journals, Journal Articles and Websites This guide will provide some tips for evaluating the books, articles and websites you find when researching for an assessment task.
Websites Advantages: Websites provide up-to-the minute news and information about current events, trends, and controversial topics. Report a problem. Subjects: How do I.?
The Purpose of this guide
Sep 20, · Non-scholarly sources: Might be written by a professional writer who is not an expert in the field. Don’t always name the authors. Are written about events, and political, moral, or ethnic opinions. Use ordinary language because they are aimed at a Author: Jennifer Doak. Dec 09, · Whereas many scholarly articles do not have a month or a month and day associated with their publication, magazine and newspaper articles almost always do. The month or month and day of the magazine or newspaper articles is accordingly added to the citation -- unlike a citation for a scholarly article, where noting a month or month and day of Author: Marc Langston.
If scholarly or non-scholarly sources are used in a paper, the sources can greatly affect the quality of the paper. Most of us have heard that scholarly sources should be used in our research papers. But how do we know if a source is scholarly or not?
This handout will help us answer that question so we can easily distinguish between scholarly and non- scholarly sources. Here are the five general types that can help categorize periodicals, ordered from the most scholarly to the least scholarly. Academic journals are characterized by their limitations to academic disciplines or sub- disciplines. They are intended to present original research or analysis. Their appearance is simple with graphics rarely used, and, if graphics are used, they support a point made in the article.
The articles often use technical language and are generally lengthy, with all the sources cited. The topics are commonly specialized for the field and written by scholars or researchers in the field. The audiences are usually other scholars and researchers in the chosen discipline, people with knowledge of the subject. Trade publications, also known as professional journals, focus on applications, i.
These publications are intended to inform professionals of new developments in an industry or profession, using fewer graphics than popular publications. Trade publications often discuss the practical application s of theory. Like popular publications, citations of sources are rarely given; there may, however, be a short reference list. These articles are commonly long and use jargon.
The content is both specific and deep. While these publications are usually not considered scholarly, they seem to be in a gray area. They seem to be somewhere between scholarly and non-scholarly. The audience is usually practitioners in the field.
General interest publications are intended to provide general information to a broad audience and, like popular publications, have an attractive appearance and many graphics. The articles are commonly short, and sometimes the sources are cited.
But most often, they contain no citations. The authors assume a certain level of intelligence and interest from the reader, but not special knowledge.
Popular publications are mainly intended to entertain the reader and usually endorse a viewpoint. Often, these publications have an attractive appearance and many graphics, such as photographs. The authors of these publications rarely cite their sources and often offer no citations. The articles are usually short and use simple language. Also, the content of the articles requires no specialized knowledge. Sensational publications are intended to entertain and stir curiosity.
These publications also have many photographs with citations rarely, if ever, given. The articles are short and use simple language, and the authors of these articles assume a certain level of gullibility and superstition from their readers.
Where do Internet sources fit? Now that we understand the differences between the five types of periodicals, we can now look at the characteristics of scholarly and non-scholarly sources. These characteristics can serve as a general guideline to help us determine if a source is scholarly or not.
Scholarly sources are intended to share original research or analyses of previous research. The sources are commonly heavily theoretical—focusing on presenting theory or proving it out. These sources are written by scholars or researchers for other scholars or researchers. The appearance of these sources is usually serious, with few, if any, graphics.
The articles are often lengthy and may include the specific language of the discipline. Additionally, sources in these articles are cited. These sources are typically academic journals and, in some fields, trade, or professional journals. To see the search options of a particular database, you might look at the help option of the database or contact Ask-a-Librarian.
Non-scholarly sources are intended to do several things: to provide general information, to entertain, to sell products, or to promote a viewpoint. These articles are commonly written by journalists, freelance writers or staff members and can be anonymous. These articles are written for a general audience with limited knowledge of the subject. The articles are also usually attractive in appearance and heavily illustrated.
Also characteristic—non-scholarly sources rarely cite sources used in the articles. They are often called magazines. Please see the table on the next page that compares the characteristics of scholarly and non-scholarly sources. This table is a very useful tool for determining quickly if a source is scholarly or not. To provide general information, to entertain, to sell products or to promote viewpoint s. May discuss application of theoretical knowledge trade or professional journals.
Academic or research communities, most likely with some scholarly background. University presses, scholarly presses, research organizations, professional organizations or associations. Undergo review by content experts prior to publishing peer-reviewed. Usually published quarterly or. Undergo editing by staff editors. Acceptance often based on popular appeal of topic. Usually published monthly, bi-monthly, weekly, or daily.
Sober, serious look. Often include abstracts. May include graphs and charts. Few, if any, glossy photographs. Usually attractive and heavily illustrated with glossy photographs. Often contains advertisements. Most often non-technical. Often written in a simple language. Technical terms used are usually defined. Footnotes, end notes, bibliographies, reference or works cited pages. Most often includes citations in-text and reference page s.
Rarely cite sources. Trade or professional journals may have short reference lists. Created by David Felts. View More Events. Skip to main content. Scholarly versus Non-scholarly Sources If scholarly or non-scholarly sources are used in a paper, the sources can greatly affect the quality of the paper.
Academic Journals Ex. Trade Publications Ex. General Interest Publications Ex. Popular Publications Ex. Sensational Publications Ex. Virtual Lobby. UHV students recognized during class ring celebration April 28, General audience or for audiences who have little information about a subject. Usually published quarterly or semi-annually. Often lengthy.
May include headings like methodology, literature review, further study.
<- What classes can you clep out of - How to get a senior citizen card->